I have both. The hardcase, IMO, is the way to go, longevity wise, but it costs a little more, & are slightly larger case size. I've found some 0.03" thick PVC roll to use as additional protection & helps keep the softcase from moving. So the slightly larger hardcase doesn't move as much & still fit my battery compartments & last longer. So the additional cost of the PVC roll & the softcase will get beat up a little, the hardcase in the long run is the way to go. I have one 6s softcase that took a grind spot from a spur gear, still working, but I always make sure it's good and secure. Nothing wrong with the softcase, just keep an eye on it.