i've been off-roading for years with trucks and off-road crawlers..if your vehicle is 4wd, u best have the same size tires all the way around unless you got a nice big fat wallet. also, even if your truck or car or w/e is only 2wd, your 2 driving tires better be the same size as well...diffs dont like spinning more on one side than the other..good way to burn clutchs outta the diffs.
as for when I'm wheelin, i got spools in my rig...so oddball size's in any corner, is a no no...if i destroy a rim or a tire, and we can't ether it back onto the rim...i park it..or get the spare out. i got WAY to much moeny into axles, diffs, and other components to just say heck with it and bolt some random tire on... TO the O.P. if ur buggy is 4wd, keep all 4 the same dood..my advice to you. otherwise, later on, we'll see you posting stuff about busted diffs or axles or driveshafts or something..i promise. lol